What Are the Grounds for Divorce in Indiana?
Indiana allows couples to file for divorce based primarily on no-fault grounds, meaning you do not need to prove wrongdoing by either spouse. In most cases, the court will issue a divorce if the marriage has suffered an irretrievable breakdown. However, there are additional grounds that may apply in limited circumstances, and knowing them provides clarity when preparing to file in Indianapolis.
No-Fault Divorce in Indiana
Under Indiana Code § 31-15-2-3, the primary ground for divorce is the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage, meaning the marriage is broken beyond repair. Because Indiana is a no-fault state, you do not need to prove cheating, abandonment, abuse, or any other wrongdoing by your spouse to obtain a divorce. This makes the process less confrontational and often faster, allowing both parties to focus on the more substantive issues of property division, child custody, and support rather than relitigating the marriage itself.
Additional Grounds for Divorce in Indiana
Although most divorces rely on an irretrievable breakdown of the marriage, Indiana law also recognizes limited fault-based grounds. These options are less common but may still apply in specific circumstances. The recognized grounds are also outlined in Indiana Code § 31-15-2-3, and include conviction of a felony, incurable insanity, and impotence at the time of marriage.
Conviction of a Felony
A spouse may seek a divorce if the other spouse has been convicted of a felony after the marriage. This ground focuses on the impact of serious criminal conduct on the marital relationship. The conviction must generally occur during the marriage, and documentation such as court records is typically required to support the claim. This ground may influence divorce proceedings in several ways:
- Demonstrating breakdown of the marriage: A felony conviction may support the argument that continuing the marital relationship is not practical. The legal consequences of incarceration can affect financial stability and family dynamics.
- Parenting considerations: If children are involved, the conviction may be relevant to custody or parenting time decisions. Courts examine how the circumstances affect the child’s well-being.
- Financial implications: Incarceration may affect income, ability to maintain the marital home, or responsibility for debts. These factors may influence property division discussions.
Even when this ground applies, courts still focus on equitable division of property and the best interests of any children. The conviction itself does not automatically determine the outcome of these issues.
Incurable Insanity
Indiana also allows divorce when one spouse has been incurably insane for a period of at least two years. This is a narrow ground with strict requirements. The spouse seeking divorce must show that the condition is supported by medical testimony.
This ground involves additional considerations:
- Medical documentation: Courts typically require testimony from qualified healthcare professionals confirming the diagnosis and duration. This ensures the claim is supported by reliable evidence.
- Care and financial support: Divorce based on incurable insanity may still involve ongoing support obligations. Courts may consider the needs of the affected spouse when determining financial arrangements.
- Impact on property division: The condition may affect each spouse’s ability to manage assets or maintain employment. Courts weigh these circumstances when dividing marital property.
Because this ground involves sensitive medical and legal issues, it is used infrequently. Many couples instead proceed under the no-fault standard, which avoids the need for extensive documentation.
Impotence at the Time of Marriage
Indiana also recognizes impotence at the time of marriage as a ground for divorce. This applies when one spouse was unable to engage in marital relations at the time the marriage occurred. The condition must exist at the time of the wedding rather than develop later. Important considerations include:
- Evidence requirements: Courts may require medical or other credible evidence confirming the condition existed at the time of marriage.
- Limited use: This ground is rarely invoked because many couples prefer the no-fault approach, which avoids personal and medical disclosures.
- Effect on proceedings: The ground itself does not automatically affect property division or custody. Courts still analyze those issues independently.
Because this ground involves highly personal matters, many individuals choose not to pursue it even when applicable. While uncommon, these situations are evaluated independently of the ground itself.
Do Grounds for Divorce Influence Property Division or Custody in Indiana?
Indiana courts generally separate the reason for divorce from financial and parenting decisions. So, in many cases, the specific grounds for divorce do not directly determine how property is divided or how custody is decided. Even when a fault-based ground applies, judges still follow equitable distribution principles and focus on the best interests of the child.
Under Indiana Code § 31-15-7-5, Indiana courts presume an equal division of marital property is just and reasonable. However, this presumption can be rebutted if a party presents relevant evidence showing an equal split would not be fair given the circumstances. This means the court looks at financial circumstances, contributions to the marriage, and future ability to earn income rather than the reason the marriage ended.
However, there are still circumstances behind certain grounds that may indirectly influence decisions, including:
- Financial impact of misconduct: A felony conviction or long-term medical condition may affect income, debts, or the ability to maintain the marital home. Courts may consider these realities when dividing assets.
- Parenting considerations: If a ground involves behavior that affects a child’s safety or stability, it may become relevant to custody or parenting time. Judges prioritize arrangements that support the child’s well-being.
- Support obligations: Situations involving health conditions or financial hardship may influence spousal maintenance decisions. Courts may evaluate the needs of each spouse carefully.
Although these factors can play a part, Indiana’s approach focuses on fairness and the child’s best interests rather than assigning blame. This is one reason many couples proceed under the no-fault ground even when other options are available.
Ready to Learn About Your Divorce Options? Talk to an Indianapolis Divorce Attorney at WSM
When considering filing based on the grounds recognized under Indiana law, the details of your situation can influence how your case proceeds. At WSM, we can evaluate your situation, help you understand which option fits, and advise you on what to expect next. Request a free consultation by calling (463) 241-6083 or reaching out online.
Visit Our Family Law Offices in Indianapolis
WSM Law Indianapolis
8606 Allisonville Rd Suite 110, Indianapolis, IN (46250)
Lat/Long: 39.91432879999999,-86.07593709999999
CID: 15901562872045077736
Today
Schedule Your
Consultation
Call For A Consultation 380-203-2023